When starting a new project, it is always difficult to choose an architecture pattern these days. There are so many factors to take into account and it is easy to get confused with all the hype around different patterns and technologies (see Hype Driven Development (https://blog.daftcode.pl/hype-driven-development-3469fc2e9b22)). Following are some general guidelines on when to choose a monolithic web application architecture over a microservice architecture and vice versa.
Choosing the right pattern
When to choose a monolithic architecture
The following list can be used as a general guide when choosing a monolithic architecture. This is not a definitive list but gives an idea of when to go with a monolithic architecture over microservices:
- When the application scope is small and well defined, and you are sure that the application will not grow tremendously in terms of features. For example, a blog, a simple online shopping website, a simple CRUD application, and so on.
- When the team size is small, say less than eight people (it's not a hard limit but rather practical).
- When the average skill set of the team is either novice or intermediate.
- When time to market is critical.
- When you do not want to spend too much on infrastructure, monitoring, and so on.
- When your user base is rather small and you do not expect them to grow. For example, an enterprise app targeting a specific set of users.
In most practical use cases, a monolithic architecture would suffice. Read on to the next section to see when you should consider a microservice architecture over monolithic.
When to choose a microservice architecture
The following list can be used as a general guide when choosing a microservice architecture. This is not a definitive list but gives an idea of when to go with microservices architecture over a monolith. Please note that unlike choosing a monolithic architecture, the decision here is more complex and may involve cross consideration among many of the following points:
- When the application scope is large and well defined and you are sure that the application will grow tremendously in terms of features. For example, an online e-commerce store, a social media service, a video streaming service with a large user base, an API provider, and so on.
- When the team size is large, there must be enough members to effectively develop individual components independently.
- When the average skill set of the team is good and team members are confident about advanced microservice patterns.
- When time to market is not critical. The microservice architecture will take more time to get right up front.
- When you are ready to spend more on infrastructure, monitoring, and so on, in order to improve the product quality.
- When your user base is huge and you expect them to grow. For example, a social media application targeting users all over the world.
Though a monolithic architecture would suffice in most cases, investing up front in a microservice architecture will reap long-term benefits when the application grows huge.
For more on these architecture patterns, you can refer to https://articles.microservices.com/monolithic-vs-microservices-architecture-5c4848858f59.
